It Takes a Thief

The Challenge

Editor's Ranking
3.0
Average User Rating
Your Watchlist
Rate Film

Cast + Crew

John Gilling
John Temple-Smith
John Gilling
John Gilling (original story)
Gordon Dines
Bill McGuffie
Thomas N. Morahan
John Victor Smith
Jayne Mansfield, Anthony Quayle, Carl Möhner, Peter Reynolds, John Bennett, Barbara Mullen, Dermot Walsh, Patrick Holt
John Gilling’s The Challenge (US: It Takes a Thief) features one of the most perfect noir openings: a breathy female voice off-camera pleads sexily with a half-naked man, who rises from a bed in a dingy, smoke-clouded hotel room and ponders her proposition by the window, a train rumbling and a neon light flashing right outside, her naked leg finally extending upward from the camera as if excited to get what she wants. It could almost be noir parody. The woman is Billy, played as a brunette for the first act by blond bombshell Jayne Mansfield, who leads a gang of thieves and wants to bring her lover Jim (Anthony Quayle) into a gold bullion job, for which he’s ultimately sent to prison; as Jim’s the only one who knows where the loot is hidden, Billie and the gang are ready for a reunion when he gets out. Gilling sustains the noir palette throughout, rain-slicked streets reflecting streetlamp light in all directions, and Mansfield seems to be enjoying her role as a decadent villainess who still carries a torch for the man she framed (in a montage of armed robberies by her gang, Billie grins in ecstasy as she watches from the getaway car). A final sequence involving a child and a speeding train strains credulity, but it’s a lot of fun to watch.

By Michael Bayer

Share this film

Detective sergeant Gittens (Edward Judd) stays on the trail of the gang of thieves.
Jim (Anthony Quayle) reaches his limit with Billy’s (Jayne Mansfield) deceitfulness.

Film Tags

Click on a tag for other films featuring that element. Full tag descriptions are available here.

Rate+Review It Takes a Thief

Reviews from Other Users

No reviews yet.